Trusted experts
Quality Orthopaedic Care
Expert orthopaedic solutions delivered with warmth and genuine care. Dr. David Sugar combines his expertise with a personal touch—because you deserve to feel comfortable, not just treated.
WE DO NOT ACCEPT INSURANCE.
We provide Concierge Services
without concierge pricing.
Family-First Approach
Dr. Sugar asks himself, "How would I treat this person if they were my own family member?" That's the standard of care you'll receive—every single visit.
Expert You Can Trust
Board-certified orthopaedic physician with decades of experience helping Sarasota patients get back to doing what they love.
Comfortable From Start to Finish
Feeling anxious? That's normal. Dr. Sugar and his team create a relaxed, low-key atmosphere where you can ask questions and leave feeling confident about your care.
Our story
Where Excellence Meets Genuine Care
Dr. David Sugar is fascinated by the human body and quality orthopaedic techniques, but ask him about the most satisfying part of his work and he'll tell you: "People."
A Florida native deeply rooted in the Sarasota community, Dr. Sugar and his wife Stephanie have built a practice that reflects their values—warm, family-oriented, and young-at-heart. When you choose Dr. Sugar for your orthopaedic needs, you're not just getting a skilled physician; you're getting someone who considers it an honor to care for you.
-
Board-certified orthopaedic physician
-
Sarasota community leader
-
Active in humanitarian work through MASH medical missions
Proud Award Winner
We're proud to have received the Herald-Tribune
2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023 & 2024 Sarasota Readers' Choice Award for Best Local Orthopedist
Patient stories
Real feedback from our patients
Hear from our patients about their experiences and how our care helped them regain their health.
The place to go
Dr. Sugar is my go to place when I have an issue with my shoulders and my sciatica. The staff is excellent and I have always received the best care!
Jerry Orten
Shoulder and Sciatica
Part of the family
If you're looking for an outstanding orthopedic specialist in the SRQ area, Dr. Sugar is the best!
Jakob Ilardi
Recovery
Never give up!
Dr. David Sugars combines extraordinary surgical skill with genuine compassion, taking the time to make every patient feel heard, valued, and confident. His commitment to excellence changed my life, and I couldn’t recommend him more highly.
Never give up!
Nik Wallenda
Sports injury
Treated the whole family
Dr Sugar and his team have successfully treated our family’s orthopedic issues over the last 10 years including pinched nerves, carpel tunnel, knee replacement, and gel injections. He is extremely knowledgeable and takes the time to answer any questions or concerns you may have. Never once did we ever feel rushed at an appointment. But most importantly, Dr Sugar and his staff care about their patients. The entire office treats you like family which builds trust and a very positive experience.
Walt and Peggy Nizinski
Carpel tunnel and knee replacement
Highly recommend Dr. Sugar
I highly recommend Dr. Sugar and their entire staff. They diagnosed my orthopedic problems and solved them quickly with their treatment plan.
The whole process was extremely professional and productive. If you have orthopedic needs you should contact Dr. Sugar.
Chris Sabo
Recovery
Feels like home
Dr. Sugar is the Best!! He has treated my wife and I over the past 10/12 years and has our utmost trust and respect. On the few occasions that went to him for an issue that might not have been his area of expertise, he got us to the place that was best for us. Quickly! The entire “office” is so comfortable. When we walk in, no matter the circumstance, it feels like home. Like many others here in Florida at our age, we have seen many, many doctors over the years. Absolutely, none better than Dr. Sugar!
Rich & Joyce Paladino
Injury